The Effectiveness of Sarbanes-Oxley on Fraud Prevention

With the economy in shambles and investors ashonest companies are struggling to survive
weary as ever, one might start to wonder if thebetween the poor economy and massive costs
Sarbanes-Oxley act has really done anything toto keep their financials fraud-free.
prevent fraud. While we have not seen any fraudEven with Sarbanes-Oxley in effect, there are
quite as ugly as the kind that brought down Enronnews reports regularly describing the newest
and WorldCom, it is still plentiful. Fraud, it seems,ponzi scheme unearthed in the financial world.
has been slightly deterred at the corporate level,These are not your average crooks either, these
but still runs rampant throughout the financialare brilliant minds of the financial world detecting
industry. These ponzi schemes seem to bean exploit and taking advantage of it. We only
happening more and more, with former chairmanhear about the ones who get caught, but there
of NASDAQ Bernie Madeoff being involved in oneare no doubt many who skim constantly and get
worth around fifty billion dollars recently.away with it. With the economy on the fritz, it
In the early 2000s, investors and employees ofonly increases the motive for fraud. Fund
the companies involved were devastated whenmanagers and financial advisors are on the
huge corporate fraud cases emerged. This fraud,chopping block. They are the ones getting the
administered from the highest offices in theblame for poor performing stocks, and the ones
corporations, left investors with worthless shareswith their jobs on the line. With all this added
and employees with no job, and depletedpressure it is obvious why fraud can look like an
retirement funds. It was time for reform, and theeasy solution.
federal government stepped in. The PublicSo now what do we do? More legislation?
Company Accounting Reform and InvestorLegislation is not the answer here. Sarbanes-Oxley
Protection Act of 2002, or Sarbanes-Oxley, wasproved that legislation could only take us so far.
their answer to corporate fraud. SOX wasThe answer is ethics. Ethics must be emphasized
intended to make these high ranking officialsby businesses instead of profits. If we start
responsible for the legitimacy of all financialleaning towards ethics training and taking a little
statements released to the public. It also putpressure of performance it will slowly turn our
measures in place to prevent public accountingfinancial ship back in the right direction. Honesty
firms from getting too involved in theshould be the number one priority, and profits
corporations in which they prepared financialshould be number two. If you only emphasize
statements for.profits and performance, eventually fraud will rear
While Sarbanes-Oxley was no doubt a good idea,its ugly head and the entire company could be at
but it turned out to be very costly for companiesstake. If you emphasize ethics and honesty, the
trying to implement these new processes in orderprofits may not be as substantial but at least you
to comply. Now there is a situation where theknow them to be true. This sets the groundwork
companies that were responsible for the start offor a company to prosper for many years as an
this fraud panic have folded, and the ones thatethical honest corporation rather than burn out
were honest are paying a stiff penalty. Now thesequickly like a profit driven supernova.